A while back I heard the term dirt surfer, and I remember thinking it was totally annoying. It bugged me that we had to borrow another sport as an analogy, as if riding a bike needed surfing to explain it. Then, on a recent ride, I had the thought that I am, in fact, a dirt surfer. I ride for flow, going fast over roly poly hills and around corners, and a big part of that flow is having a clean, quick drivetrain.
So this review is as much about moving to electronic shifting as it is about moving to GRX. I came for the groupset. I stayed for the buttons.
This is also part one of two. I'm totally rebooting the BigLeaf's drivetrain, and step one is moving from Rival 1 to Shimano GRX. Next up, I'm moving to wax in a project with Silca.





A Hand-Me-Down Drivetrain
When I got my Neuhaus BigLeaf, I didn't really have the money to put a new drivetrain on it. So I just swapped over the 11-speed Rival 1 I was running from the factory build on my Landyachtz AB-ST and called it a day. Over the next year, I think I blamed the BigLeaf for lots of things the Rival 1 was responsible for. I didn't realize it until I got on the GRX. It's like a whole new bike. Sorry, BigLeaf. Climbing, especially. More on that later.
The drivetrain swap happened without me. Fort Street Cycle put it all together while I was on a work trip to India, and I came back to having it done and complete. That was really nice. There was one thing missing, the bottom bracket, which doesn't come with the crank, and the guys sorted that too.
Electronic was new to me, so they did a bit of a demo. How to turn it on, how to check my batteries, how to charge them. The whole setup is totally wireless, with the battery sitting right on the derailleur. The Tibet skeptic in me took notes. I've been riding since the mid-nineties and had never once plugged in a drivetrain.






The Tibet Problem
I've fought moving to electronic for years. And it wasn't because I ever really tried it. It came down to one silly assumption I had, that mechanical was more reliable. Every time electronic came up in conversation, I'd bring up the same situation. What happens if I'm in the backcountry of Tibet and my drive craps out.
Well, guess what?! The number of times I've been in remote Tibet with a problem, at all, is zero. And so far, the battery hasn’t died on me either. A few months in, battery life hasn't even been an issue, and I can charge it just as easily as my GPS watch. I'll let you know if either changes.
Tap, Tap, Tap
Thirty-plus years of riding bikes has built me a very mechanical mind. So on my first rides, shifting felt like there was a nanosecond every time I tapped the shifter where I was praying the gear was actually going to change. And of course, it always does. It's just putting your faith in the electronics. It took a little more time than I expected, at least a few rides.
However, I will say, tapping to shift a gear is so much fun. I mean, it is crazy. With my Rival 1, I really had to crank on the lever to the side to shift up, and depending on the condition of my cable, sometimes I had to really reef on it. Now I barely move a finger.

One button goes up and one goes down. Simple. And yet, on those first rides, I kept pressing the wrong one at the wrong time. That faded fast. On day two I rode the same daily 60 km I always do, which is the best way to test a new drive because I could really see the difference. Everything felt smoother and faster, maybe because I was getting used to the shifting and wasn't making mistakes anymore. The nanosecond of praying was gone too. I'd gotten into the rhythm of it, and for a dirt surfer, rhythm is the whole point.
The shifters themselves are lovely. They're not as thick as the Rival 1, so my hand just kind of sits more naturally on them, and they feel lighter and faster. I put on some new Camp & Go Slow tape too, which I always love on this bike.
I'll admit I didn't love the squared-off brake levers at first. Now I do. I can brake with one finger on each lever, where my Rival 1 needed two or three fingers each to get a good stop. That's of course not up to the levers alone, I understand that, but trusting one finger is totally new for me.







Climbing Like a Goat
Climbing on the BigLeaf always felt a little tougher than it should have. For some reason, I blamed its shorter wheelbase compared to my Landyachtz AB-ST. Now I realize it was just a ratio problem with the Rival 1.
I absolutely love having the wider cassette. The Rival 1 topped out at an 11-42. The GRX build runs a 40T crank with a 10-51 XT cassette, and those extra teeth let me climb like I used to on my Krampus. Just sit back and slow climb like a goat. Something I wasn't really able to do on the narrower Rival 1. Being able to do that on a gravel bike is happy days.
The whole setup feels amazing, and it hasn't missed a shift yet. I'm up out of the saddle and climbing better than I ever have, quickly and nimbly thanks to the extra range. You can hold down the shifter to run all the way through the cassette, but I’ve never found a reason to.



The ratio just makes so much more sense for the type of riding I do. In the singletrack I get into a rhythm with shifting way easier, because it's just tap, tap, tap. That's the dirt surfer in me talking. The whole bike feels faster, more nimble, and way more fun.
Conclusion
I've been riding it for a few months now, and the drive just seems to get better and better. It only took 30 km for me to know I was a lifer. There is no going back. It's just too good. It’s like swapping to 29ers or going tubeless. Wireless is like that. Once you do it, everything else seems silly. The Tibet skeptic in me still wants a word, though the honest version of that fear is a dead battery somewhere on the Galloping Goose. I'll likely be close enough to home to coast.
The price is not cheap, of course, but that's what you get for the latest and greatest. It has changed my ride completely, and I think it's worth every penny. I can't really compare it against SRAM AXS, but I will say that moving from SRAM back to Shimano felt like coming home. I absolutely love it.
So yeah, I'm a dirt surfer. I still think the term is annoying. Turns out the board matters.

Pros
- Tap to shift is light, fast, and genuinely fun.
- Slimmer hoods than the Rival 1 that sit naturally in the hand.
- One-finger braking on each lever.
- The 10-51 range brings back sit-and-spin goat climbing on a gravel bike.
- Fully wireless, with the battery right on the derailleur.
Cons
- Easy to mix up the up and down buttons, especially on the first few rides.
- Batteries need to be checked and charged.
- The squared-off brake levers take some getting used to.
- Expensive.


